BY PIE NEWSDESK
1. The ruling in brief
North West businessman Suliman Carrim, a former ANC regional treasurer, was refused bail by the Musina Magistrate’s Court on Monday 16 November 2026. The application was brought under Schedule 5 of the Criminal Procedure Act, which puts the onus on the accused. The court found that Carrim had not discharged that onus and that his release was not in the interests of justice. He stays in custody, and the matter was postponed to 23 November for further investigation and possible transfer to the regional court.
The ruling matters beyond the Musina case. Carrim had already won R100 000 bail in Pretoria on 28 October, in a separate case over his repeated failure to appear before the Madlanga Commission. That bail never freed him because the Musina matter kept him in custody. The Madlanga case then came back to count against him.
How the Madlanga condition unravelled
The Pretoria Magistrate’s Court (Magistrate Marc Curlewis) imposed 12 conditions. They included surrendering his passport, reporting weekly to a police station, and a requirement that his lawyer report in person to the commission within 48 hours to arrange his next appearance. On 30 October the commission said that the condition had not been met. At Musina the State used this to argue that Carrim could not be trusted to comply with court orders.
The defence disputed this. It said the condition was aimed at his lawyers, who wrote to the commission within 48 hours, and it pointed to inpatient records in support of his illness claims. One report also said Carrim had since made contact with the commission. The Musina court was not persuaded.
2. The magistrate’s reasons, as reported
The reasons below come from the reports of the judgment listed in section 7. They are paraphrased, not verbatim.
- Onus not discharged. The court was not satisfied that Carrim had discharged the onus on him and found his release “not permissible” in the interests of justice. It closed with the words “The accused is to remain in custody.” It also accepted the State’s argument that release could undermine the proper functioning of the criminal justice system, including the bail system.
- The Madlanga bail condition. The magistrate raised his failure to make arrangements with the commission within 48 hours, as the Pretoria court had directed. One report says this raised questions about his honesty and his willingness to comply with court orders.
- Undisclosed assets. The court found that Carrim had failed to disclose eight properties and interests in several companies. These included properties registered in his name and under ZIP Investment CC. The State also raised properties in Dubai reportedly worth more than R8 million, plus vehicles and other financial interests.
- No proof of his finances. He did not give the court proof of his financial position.
- The second wife’s address. He did not provide the residential address of his second wife for police verification.
- Flight risk. Carrim was arrested at OR Tambo International Airport on 15 October while preparing to fly to Dubai. The court questioned whether his return ticket was enough to show he would come back. The State pointed to his UAE residence permit and international connections. Carrim said the trip was a religious pilgrimage to Saudi Arabia and that he had surrendered his passport and held no other travel documents.
- Strength of the State’s case. The magistrate said the State had presented a prima facie case. Whether a bank letter he calls fraudulent is genuine will be decided by the trial court.
What the defence argued
- Carrim denies both counts of attempted theft and says the vehicles were being moved for a temporary family trip and to carry groceries.
- The defence challenged the legality of WhatsApp messages taken from his phone without a warrant after his arrest.
- It argued that the Madlanga proceedings should not automatically decide the Musina bail outcome.
3. The Musina case
Carrim faces seven charges: two counts of attempted theft, two of uttering, one of money laundering, and two of employing foreign nationals without valid work permits. The State alleges that on 22 July police intercepted two Absa-financed BAIC X55 vehicles, each valued at R434 600, at the Beitbridge border post. The vehicles allegedly came from Mahikeng and were bound for Malawi, and the State says fraudulent bank letters were used to move them.
Two employees are co-accused. The Citizen names them as Malawian nationals Mike Phiri Mussa and Ibrahim Zakes. The NPA alleges Carrim colluded with employees, including his private chef.
Separately, he faces a Commissions Act charge in Pretoria for failing to appear before the Madlanga Commission, and that matter returns to court on 8 December. Before the commission he had said he lost R8.4 million after funding Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala’s healthcare company, claiming he was misled by Matlala and Brown Mogotsi.
4. Where everyone stands
Some prominent names are in custody, several are free on bail (including the former Idac head), two major cases have been withdrawn, and neither the suspended police minister, Senzo Mchunu, nor his predecessor, Bheki Cele, has been charged.
In custody
| Name | Role and case | Status | Next step |
| Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala | Alleged cartel figure. Medicare24 tender fraud case, plus a separate case with 25 charges including attempted murder. | Remains in custody; the other Medicare24 accused are out on bail. He testified at the commission on 9–10 November. | 17 Nov: Medicare24 case back in court (under NPA review) |
| Shadrack Sibiya | Former deputy national commissioner. Charges include rape, sexual grooming of a minor, human trafficking and negligent firearm handling. He denies wrongdoing. | Bail refused 20 October (Randburg). Resigned from SAPS on 12 October. Bail appeal filed 5 November. | 24 Nov: Randburg court |
| Suliman Carrim | Businessman. Musina vehicle-smuggling case and Commissions Act charge. | Bail refused 16 November in Musina; R100 000 Pretoria bail does not free him. | 23 Nov: Musina; 8 Dec: Pretoria |
| Brown Mogotsi | Political fixer. Accused of staging his own November 2025 shooting. Perjury and defeating-the-ends-of-justice charges, among others. | Refused bail four times. Prosecutors alleged a plan to slip out of court cells dressed as a prison official. | Pre-trial |
| Fannie Nkosi | Suspended Gauteng organised-crime sergeant. 13 charges across Gauteng and Limpopo. | Remains behind bars after bail was denied in April. | Pending |
| Julius Mkhwanazi | Former Ekurhuleni metro police deputy chief, fired in September. Murder, kidnapping, robbery and fraud-related cases (five in all). | Refused bail in the Brakpan murder matter; out on bail in one fraud case. | Multiple cases |
Out on bail
| Name | Role and case | Status | Next step |
| Katiso “KT” Molefe | Businessman accused of masterminding the 2022 murder of DJ Sumbody and two bodyguards. | R400 000 bail (High Court). Bail extended in October. | Trial postponed to 19 July 2027 |
| Feroz Khan | Dismissed Crime Intelligence deputy head. Two cases: the precious metals case (defeating the ends of justice, Precious Metals Act) and, with Johnson, a 30 October arrest over an assault docket. Shot in an alleged assassination attempt before his commission appearance. | R20 000 bail in the precious metals case (May) and R10 000 in the Johnson case (30 Oct; State did not oppose). His commission appearance was postponed indefinitely. | 2 Feb 2027: Pretoria (Johnson case) |
| Ebrahim Kadwa | Gauteng Hawks head. Same precious metals case as Khan. | R20 000 bail since May. | Case in Kempton Park court |
| Andrea Johnson | Former head of the Investigating Directorate Against Corruption. Charged with defeating the ends of justice, assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm (as accessory after the fact) and contravening the NPA Act. The State alleges she gave Khan information from an assault docket against him. | Arrested 30 October; R10 000 bail in Pretoria, unopposed because the offences fall under Schedule 1. | 2 Feb 2027: Pretoria |
| Imogen Mashazi | Former Ekurhuleni city manager. Fraud, corruption and defeating-the-ends-of-justice charges. | R50 000 bail. | Pending |
| Other Medicare24 accused | Senior police officers and company directors in the R228 million tender case. | Out on bail, as reported on 29 September. | NPA review under way |
Charges withdrawn or cleared
| Name | Role and case | Status | Next step |
| Fannie Masemola | National police commissioner, charged in the Medicare24 matter. | NDPP ordered charges withdrawn on 15 September; court formally withdrew them on 22 September; Ramaphosa reinstated him from 19 October. | Back at work |
| Dumisani Khumalo | Crime Intelligence head. Fraud and corruption case. | NPA withdrew all charges against him and six co-accused in August. | Cleared |
Not charged, still in the sights of the commission and lawmakers
| Name | Role and case | Status | Next step |
| Senzo Mchunu | Current (suspended) police minister, on special leave since 13 July 2025. Firoz Cachalia is acting minister. | No public findings against him from the commission or the parliamentary ad hoc committee. The committee’s draft report found no link to criminal networks but raised unresolved integrity concerns. | Expected to testify; no date. Ramaphosa says he will act after the final report |
| Bheki Cele | Former police minister (before Mchunu). Matlala told Parliament’s ad hoc committee he paid Cele R500 000 in two cash instalments. Cele denies receiving any payments from Matlala. | Not charged. In October the ad hoc committee recommended a Hawks investigation into the alleged payments. Matlala’s later commission testimony on the money differed from what he told Parliament. | Hawks probe recommended; no charges reported |
| Others named by commentators | An IOL Politics analysis (11 November) lists presidential adviser Bejani Chauke, Ze Nxumalo, Steven Motsumi, “King Nyambose” Mtetwa, Hangwani Maumela and Paul O’Sullivan as figures the commission should still call. | The analysis reports a rule 10.6 notice to Chauke. These are commentary and untested allegations; none of these men is reported as charged. | Unclear |
5. Reading the tally
Cases flowing from the commission have netted generals, a metro police deputy chief, a city manager and several businessmen, so the “notch stick” description in Daily Maverick’s October analysis is fair. But three caveats apply before anyone writes that the big fish are all inside.
- Custody is not conviction. Almost nobody listed has been tried. Matlala’s plea deal collapsed in July, leaving the NPA to rebuild its Medicare24 case without his admissions, and that case is now under review.
- Some prosecutions have collapsed. The withdrawals for Masemola and for Khumalo’s group, and the review of Idac cases, show the state’s own investigators were also under scrutiny. Idac’s former head, Andrea Johnson, is now an accused herself.
- The political tier is untouched. Mchunu has not been charged or found against, and the final report is not due until 25 January 2027 after Ramaphosa’s final extension.
6. Dates to watch
| Date | Event |
| 17 Nov 2026 | Matlala and co-accused, Medicare24 case, Pretoria (NPA review ongoing) |
| 23 Nov 2026 | Carrim, Musina: further investigation and possible transfer to the regional court |
| 24 Nov 2026 | Sibiya, Randburg Magistrate’s Court |
| 8 Dec 2026 | Carrim, Pretoria: docket disclosure in the Madlanga non-appearance case |
| 25 Jan 2027 | Final deadline for the Madlanga Commission’s final report |
| 2 Feb 2027 | Johnson and Khan, Pretoria Magistrate’s Court: defeating the ends of justice case, postponed for further investigation |
| 19 Jul 2027 | Katiso Molefe and co-accused, DJ Sumbody murder trial, Johannesburg High Court |