VIEWPOINT: Nhlanhla Mbatha
A week before local elections, in any normal democracy, you know who wants to be your mayor.
In Johannesburg, you would know if the ANC candidate is Dada Morero, Loyiso Masuku, or someone new. In Ekurhuleni, you would know if it is Doctor Xhakaza returning.
In Soweto, you would know who the ANC wants for Ward 14, Ward 36, Ward 11.
We do not know. And we have already voted.
Today, the ANC has not published its list of mayoral and councilor candidates. Not on its website. Not at Luthuli House. Not at the provincial office in Commissioner Street.
That is not an oversight. That is a strategy. And it is what I call politics of blindness and surprise.
In ANC culture, there is this old belief: the movement is bigger than the individual. You vote for the ANC, not for the person. The ANC will then deploy the right cadre after the election. They call it democratic centralism.
But that time is over. We are not in 1994 when we voted for Nelson Mandela’s face. We are in 2026 where sewage runs in the streets and we want to know who will fix it. When ANC hides its candidates, it is telling us three things.
First, it is hiding from its own failures. If they publish that the same councilor who failed in a ward for five years is coming back, people will revolt before election day. In 2021, many ANC ward councilors in Soweto lost because residents knew them – they were the ones who never attended community meetings. The ANC learned the lesson, but the wrong lesson. Instead of changing the candidates, they decided to hide them until after we had voted.
Second, it is protecting internal factions, not voters. Everyone knows that the ANC in Gauteng is split into three camps – Panyaza Lesufi’s camp, Hope Papo’s camp, and the RET camp that supports Ace Magashule and Jacob Zuma. If they announce a mayor for Johannesburg before elections, other camps will campaign against him. So, they keep all factions in suspense. That is blind leadership. The leader is blind to the electorate, but sees very well inside Luthuli House.
Third, it kills media hype. media. Independent candidates walk the street. ActionSA publishes their own mayoral candidate. DA publishes. They are all in the media. The electorate is empowered. But ANC, the oldest liberation movement, says “trust us.” Trust us with what? The City of Joburg has had 8 mayors in 3 years. Ekurhuleni is bankrupt. Yet they want us to give a blank cheque.
The Electoral Act does not require a party to publish mayoral candidates. Legally, they can do this. You vote for a party, and after the election, the party caucus elects the mayor. That is legal.
But legal does not mean democratic. It is the same legal trick used in 2021 when ANC lost 32% nationally but still made mayors through coalitions no one voted for. What is the consequence? Blind voting produces blind accountability. If I don’t know who I voted for as mayor, how do I hold they accountable for promises they never made in public?
The ANC says it will announce after candidate verification by the ANC integrity committee. But verification should have been done months earlier, not after the election.
The real reason is fear – fear that communities will reject imposed candidates from above, as they did in Tshwane in 2016 when Thoko Didiza was imposed and ANC lost Tshwane for the first time.
South Africans are not blind. In 2024 they showed that. They split their vote. In 2026 local, same story. If ANC wants to surprise South Africa, South Africa will surprise it. Voters will vote for the face they know in the street, an independent candidate who has no party logo. A known independent is better than an unknown comrade.
Voters deserve to see who they are hiring to fix their street, before they hire them. Otherwise, this is not an election. It is a lottery.
- Mbatha is a current affairs analyst