CAPTION: ANC CHAIRPERSON GWEDE MANTASHE – ” ANC LOSS MEANS DEMOCRACY IS MATURING….”
BY IDO LEKOTA
There is something almost majestic about the way the ANC has responded to its latest electoral setback. Faced with voters abandoning the party in significant numbers, ANC chairperson Gwede Mantashe did not reach instinctively for the mirror, the audit report, or the long catalogue of broken promises. Instead, he reached for a far more comforting explanation: democracy is maturing.
South Africans, he reminded us, enjoy the freedom to associate and, crucially, the freedom to disassociate. Voters are now exercising that freedom by exploring alternatives to the governing party. How admirable. The ANC has apparently rediscovered that the democratic system it helped establish contains a small but inconvenient feature: citizens are free to use it against the ANC itself.
One can almost imagine the scene at the results operations centre. The numbers are falling, support is draining away, and anxious officials gather around the latest projections. Someone asks, “Why are voters leaving?” Mantashe replies, “Because democracy is maturing.” Another asks, “But why are they choosing other parties?” An uncomfortable silence descends. A committee is promptly appointed to investigate the philosophical implications of freedom.
The exchange may be imaginary, but it captures a very real problem. In explaining voter behaviour, the ANC appears more interested in celebrating the existence of choice than understanding why so many citizens are making choices that no longer favour the party.
The Freedom to Leave
To be fair, Mantashe’s observation contains an important truth. In a healthy democracy, citizens must be free to change political allegiances, form new movements, support opposition parties and remove governments through the ballot box. Political competition is indeed evidence that voters are not the permanent property of any political organisation.
But that is only half the story and, conveniently for the ANC, the more flattering half.
The ANC may have helped create the democratic space in which alternatives can emerge, but it did not create the reasons voters are searching for them. Democracy provides the exit door. The ANC’s performance encouraged citizens to walk through it.
More than fifty years ago, economist and political theorist Albert Hirschman, in Exit, Voice and Loyalty (1970), argued that dissatisfied citizens and consumers generally respond to institutional failure in one of two ways: they either exercise “voice” by attempting to reform the institution from within, or they exercise “exit” by leaving it altogether.
What Mantashe celebrates as democratic maturity may simply be an unprecedented exercise in political exit. The troubling question for the ANC is not whether voters have the freedom to leave. It is why so many have concluded that voicing their frustrations within the party’s political orbit no longer produces meaningful results.
That distinction is critical.
The existence of alternatives explains how voters can leave. It does not explain why they want to leave. Yet it is precisely that question that the ANC’s explanation carefully sidesteps.

If the party were delivering effective local government, maintaining infrastructure, combating corruption, managing municipalities competently and inspiring confidence in its leadership, the mere presence of competing political parties would not automatically translate into collapsing support. Competition becomes dangerous only when voters no longer believe that the incumbent remains their best option.
The real question is not whether democracy is maturing. The real question is what the ANC has done to make so many voters feel that their future may lie elsewhere.
The American philosopher John Dewey warned that democracy is not merely a set of institutions but a continuous process of public accountability. Elections are not ceremonies that validate governments; they are mechanisms through which citizens evaluate them. From that perspective, declining support is not evidence that democracy has matured independently of the ANC. It is evidence that democratic accountability is functioning precisely as intended.
The Numbers Refuse to Applaud
The election results themselves are considerably less enthusiastic about the “maturing democracy” explanation than the ANC leadership appears to be.
The party’s support fell dramatically from its performance in the 2021 municipal elections. Whatever language one chooses to use, this was not a minor correction or a routine fluctuation. It represented a substantial withdrawal of confidence from a significant section of the electorate.
The ANC may come out as the largest political party nationally, but size and dominance are no longer the same thing.
The German sociologist Max Weber distinguished between power and legitimacy. Power allows a government to rule; legitimacy persuades citizens that it deserves to rule. Electoral decline often begins long before power is lost. It begins when legitimacy starts to erode. The ANC’s challenge is not simply numerical. It is that growing numbers of voters appear unconvinced by its claim to be the country’s natural governing party.
There was a time when electoral setbacks merely reduced the scale of ANC victories. Increasingly, however, elections are raising more fundamental questions about the party’s political standing and future trajectory.
Particularly revealing was the gap between the party’s expectations and electoral reality. During the counting process, optimistic projections suggested that support might recover significantly as more results came in. Instead, the opposite occurred. The anticipated resurgence hasn’t materialised.
This is the uncomfortable arithmetic of decline. Hope may remain abundant within the party, but voters appear increasingly reluctant to participate in it.
The Metro Problem
Nowhere is the ANC’s predicament more visible than in South Africa’s metropolitan municipalities.
The metros are not just administrative units. They are the country’s principal centres of economic activity, investment and urban governance. They are where potholes are noticed quickly, infrastructure failures are impossible to ignore and service delivery is tested daily by millions of residents.
The results from several major metros paint a troubling picture for a party that still considers itself the natural governing force of South African politics.
These were not isolated losses in distant rural municipalities. They occurred in the country’s major urban centres, where governance performance is constantly visible and where residents have multiple opportunities to compare promises with outcomes.
The significance of such losses extends beyond percentages. Political influence depends not merely on historical stature but on the capacity to persuade citizens that a party remains capable of governing effectively. When support declines sharply in economic and administrative hubs, questions about relevance and credibility inevitably follow.
The ANC can insist that it remains influential. Yet there comes a point at which influence risks becoming a euphemism for diminishing support. Political power is ultimately measured not by memories of former strength but by the willingness of citizens to renew their confidence.
Writing about democracy in nineteenth-century America, Alexis de Tocqueville observed that democratic societies constantly subject authority to public judgement. Unlike monarchies, where legitimacy is inherited, democratic governments must repeatedly earn it. Liberation movements that become governing parties often struggle with this transition. Historic achievements may secure admiration, but they cannot permanently secure consent.
A Party Admiring Its Own Reflection
The response to the election results reveals a habit that has become increasingly familiar within the ANC. When confronted with an adverse judgement from the electorate, the party often turns inward and seeks reassurance in its historical achievements.
Ironically, this tendency was anticipated by Political Philosopher Frantz Fanon, who warned in The Wretched of the Earth that post-liberation ruling elites could become trapped in the prestige of their revolutionary past. Rather than drawing legitimacy from ongoing service to the people, they begin to rely on the symbolic capital accumulated during the liberation struggle. The danger is not merely complacency. It is the gradual substitution of historical memory for political performance.
Voters are discussing governance, accountability and service delivery.
The ANC is discussing the freedom it gave them.
Citizens are asking whether the party still deserves their confidence.
The ANC is reminding them that it once deserved their gratitude.
This is a subtle but significant shift in focus. Instead of interrogating why support is declining, the party highlights its role in creating the democratic environment within which that decline is occurring.
The result is a form of political navel-gazing disguised as analysis.
In this account, the ANC does not lose support because it has failed. It loses support because democracy has succeeded. The party is not being rejected. It is merely being honoured for establishing the conditions that allow voters to reject it.
It is an elegant argument. It is also one that risks teaching the ANC absolutely nothing about the message voters are trying to send.
The Question That Refuses to Go Away
The growing number of political parties on the ballot explains the availability of alternatives. It does not explain their appeal.
Why are voters choosing them?
Are citizens reacting to deteriorating municipal services, collapsing infrastructure, persistent corruption, unreliable water and electricity provision, unemployment, factional battles, or unfulfilled promises of renewal?
Is the problem governance?
Leadership?
Trust?
The ANC’s explanation offers remarkably little insight into any of these possibilities.
Freedom is not a political alibi. It is a mechanism of accountability.
German-born Theorist Hannah Arendt argued that freedom acquires meaning only when citizens can act politically and hold power to account. Elections are one of the principal means through which that accountability is exercised. To invoke democratic freedom as an explanation for electoral decline risks confusing cause and consequence. Democracy did not create dissatisfaction. It merely provided citizens with a peaceful means of expressing it.
The fact that citizens possess the freedom to leave is not the story. The story is that increasing numbers of them are deciding to use it.
The ANC may proudly remind South Africans that it helped secure the right to disassociate. Voters appear increasingly willing to respond, “Thank you. We have exercised it.”
Renewal in the Rear-View Mirror
The election response also raises broader questions about the sincerity of the ANC’s much-publicised renewal project.
Renewal is not a slogan. It is a process of self-examination. It requires organisations to identify failures, accept responsibility and alter behaviour. It demands a willingness to confront uncomfortable truths rather than reinterpret them as evidence of success.
A genuinely renewed organisation would approach electoral decline as a warning signal.
It would ask why historical loyalty no longer guarantees contemporary support.
It would investigate why trust has weakened.
It would seek to understand why so many people who once supported the ANC now feel comfortable placing their faith elsewhere.
Instead, the response appears defensive rather than reflective. The party seems more willing to celebrate democracy than to examine its own contribution to the frustrations being expressed through democratic participation.
The Cost of Not Looking Up
Navel-gazing is only harmless when one eventually looks up.
If the ANC remains preoccupied with its own history, it risks overlooking the political landscape changing around it. Liberation credentials remain historically important. Organisational reach remains valuable. The ANC’s contribution to South Africa’s democratic transition remains undeniable.
But none of these guarantees future support.
Historical significance is not the same as public trust. Liberation legitimacy is not a substitute for competent government. Yesterday’s achievements cannot permanently compensate for today’s failures.
This is a challenge that has confronted many former liberation movements once the struggle itself recedes from living memory.
South African political analyst Professor Xolela Mangcu has observed that liberation movements often face a legitimacy dilemma when liberation becomes history rather than lived experience. As new generations enter political life, struggle credentials increasingly compete with more immediate concerns such as governance, employment, service delivery and institutional performance. The ANC’s electoral challenge may therefore be less about the growth of opposition parties than about the diminishing political returns of liberation nostalgia.
The danger is therefore obvious. If every electoral setback is interpreted primarily as evidence of democratic maturity, the ANC may become increasingly adept at explaining its decline while becoming progressively less capable of reversing it.
At some point, the party will have to choose between admiring the freedom it says it gave South Africans and confronting what South Africans are using that freedom to say.
Their message is becoming increasingly difficult to misinterpret.
They are saying that the ANC’s past, however significant, cannot govern the present.
And unless the party develops the courage to look beyond its reflection, democracy may continue maturing while the ANC continues explaining its decline from the comfort of the mirror.
Italian Antonio Gramsci observed, a crisis emerges when “the old is dying and the new cannot be born.” The ANC’s challenge is not that South Africans have forgotten its historic role. It is that an increasing number of voters have begun to distinguish between gratitude for the past and confidence in the future.
Historical significance is not the same as public trust. Liberation legitimacy is not a substitute for competent government. Yesterday’s achievements cannot permanently compensate for today’s failures.