Home » Blog » Tenderpreneurship Is About Conduct, Not Race

Tenderpreneurship Is About Conduct, Not Race

by Len Kalane

PIC: IDO LEKOTA

 IDO LEKOTA

A response to my recent article (See PiE MAGAZINE) raised a concern worth addressing: the word “tenderpreneur” can be used to cast suspicion on black business success, while large, established companies that secure substantial government contracts may escape the same label.

That concern is legitimate. The term can be applied carelessly, and criticism of public procurement must never become a way to disparage black entrepreneurs simply because they are successful or receive state contracts. But that was not the argument in my article. My criticism was directed at conduct, not race.

Winning a government tender does not, on its own, make a business a tenderpreneur. Public procurement is a legitimate way for the state to obtain goods and services, and businesses of every size and ownership structure may compete for that work. The relevant questions are whether the process was fair, whether the contractor delivered, and whether the public received value.

The distinction is between productive enterprise and rent-seeking. A business that competes fairly, fulfils its obligations and builds lasting capacity is engaged in legitimate enterprise. A business that depends chiefly on political access, opaque dealings or the extraction of public money without commensurate value is a different matter. That is the behaviour I describe as tenderpreneurship.

The same standard must apply to all. If major law firms, auditing firms, retailers or other established companies secure public contracts, they should face the same scrutiny as any other contractor. Their size, reputation or ownership should not shield them from questions about how contracts were awarded and whether they delivered what they promised.

Nor should the term “tenderpreneur” be used as a shortcut for dismissing black-owned businesses. Where the label is applied without evidence, it is unfair and undermines a serious debate about procurement. We should judge businesses by what they do—not by assumptions about who owns them.

There is no contradiction in supporting fair access to public contracts, including for black businesses, while opposing corruption, patronage and poor value for money. Indeed, consistent scrutiny protects legitimate entrepreneurs by distinguishing them from those who exploit the system.

The debate should not be about whether a tender recipient is black or white. It should be about whether the business creates value, meets its obligations and competes fairly – and have an actual business address (and registered employees). That is the distinction my article sought to make.

You may also like

PiE Digital Afrika
PiE Digital Afrika
GoogleGoogleGoogleGoogleGoogle
4 Google reviews