Home » Blog » Hung Councils: The Ins and Outs

Hung Councils: The Ins and Outs

by Len Kalane

By IDO LEKOTA

South Africa’s 2026 local-government elections—in which more than 60% of councils were hung, meaning no party secured an outright majority—have confirmed a new political reality: coalition government is no longer an anomaly; it is the country’s dominant form of local governance.

Seven of the country’s eight metropolitan municipalities required coalition arrangements, leaving Cape Town as the sole metro exception. This outcome has shifted power decisively from party headquarters to council chambers, where mayors require multiparty support, budgets demand negotiated consent, and parties long accustomed to unilateral dominance must learn the discipline of governing with others.

This shift was not necessarily an endorsement of every backroom coalition deal. Rather, it was an endorsement of a more plural political order in which parties must negotiate, share power, and earn governing majorities through cooperation. The democratic instruction is clear: coalition government must graduate from an emergency arrangement into a credible, institutionalized system of local governance.

That instruction comes with a warning. Hung councils create the possibility of cooperation, but they do not guarantee good governance. Parties can use fragmented councils to haggle over positions, destabilize administrations, and trade support for narrow, factional interests—or they can build transparent, service-oriented partnerships capable of restoring municipal institutions and improving residents’ quality of life.

The choice confronting South Africa is no longer whether coalition government will exist; the electorate has answered that. The choice is whether coalitions will become vehicles for public value and institutional renewal—or merely new arenas for political horse-trading.


The Post-Election Challenge

The 2026 negotiations unfold against the backdrop of lessons learned during the 2023–2025 coalition period. While the Mistra Coalitions Barometer II noted a relative calming of local coalition politics during those years, it also revealed a persistent truth: coalition partnerships do not eliminate internal contestation. Parties frequently cooperate while simultaneously competing, challenging one another, and using coalition membership to build future electoral strength. The ANC–DA relationship within the national Government of National Unity (GNU) illustrates this dynamic precisely—cooperation at the executive level has not ended political rivalry.

This creates a central dilemma for post-2026 negotiations. Coalition partners must cooperate closely enough to govern effectively, yet remain politically distinct enough to preserve their identities and electoral prospects. The result is often acrimonious coalition politics, even among parties that derive mutual advantage from staying in power.

Furthermore, the Barometer found that few parties have truly accepted coalition governance as an enduring structural reality. Instead, many continue to treat coalition status as a tactical weapon for future electoral positioning. This mindset threatens to turn every budget vote, key appointment, procurement decision, and council debate into a grueling test of leverage.

Consequently, the 2026 negotiations begin with a difficult reality: parties may be willing to form coalitions, but many remain reluctant to accept the fundamental obligations of shared governance. A coalition built merely to capture or retain office will inevitably struggle to deliver public value.


The GNU Effect

The national Government of National Unity has inevitably cast a shadow over local coalition dynamics. According to the Barometer, national cooperation helped elevate the ANC’s status, while small and micro parties leveraged their associations with major players to secure influence and help the ANC regain footing in several municipalities.

This dynamic complicates post-2026 local negotiations. Parties may be tempted to mechanically replicate national arrangements at the municipal level, ignoring local conditions, unique voter alignments, and specific service-delivery needs. Tying municipal choices to national calculations risks subordinating local accountability to broader party headquarters strategies.

Yet, local parties have frequently demonstrated autonomy, noting that national or provincial partnerships do not strictly dictate municipal-level alliances. While this flexibility reflects democratic pluralism, it can also baffle voters. A party may support the ANC nationally, oppose it locally, or partner with the DA in one municipality while working with the EFF in another. Such fluidity makes it difficult for residents to hold anyone accountable.

The central question remains whether parties can rigorously distinguish between electoral competition and governing responsibility.

They may compete for future votes, but they must not allow that competition to become an excuse for obstruction, instability, or the politicization of municipal administration.


Stability Is Not Performance

Coalition governments are frequently dismissed as inherently unstable, but that diagnosis is too simplistic. Their success or failure depends heavily on local political relationships, administrative capacity, and clear mechanisms for managing disagreement.

A more vital distinction must be made between political stability and governance effectiveness. A coalition may manage to cling to power while water systems fail, infrastructure decays, finances deteriorate, and procurement becomes politicized. Conversely, a politically contested council can still deliver if its professional administration is shielded from constant interference.

The Mistra Barometer highlighted that coalition performance across spheres has often been undermined by constrained state capacity and an inability to align policy implementation with popular needs. National and provincial instability further exacerbated this bureaucratic friction.

Therefore, the ultimate objective should not be coalition survival at any cost. It must be stable, accountable, and developmental governance.

Begin with a Governing Compact

Coalition negotiations should never begin with the question of who gets the mayoralty. They should begin with a municipality’s most urgent crises and a concrete plan to resolve them.

A viable coalition agreement must be public. It should outline a limited, fully costed service-delivery program with clear timelines, explicit budget priorities and sustainable funding sources, transparent decision-making alongside formal dispute-resolution procedures, and strict rules regarding the replacement of office-bearers paired with robust ethical commitments.

Agreements must function as instruments of public accountability rather than private contracts for dividing political spoils. The guiding question for any incoming alliance is simple: What will residents experience differently within the first year of this coalition?

Answering that question requires a candid diagnosis of failing water and electricity grids, deteriorating roads, weak revenue collection, unauthorized expenditure, and technical vacancies—followed by a disciplined focus on a manageable number of measurable priorities. A coalition that promises everything will deliver nothing.


Protect the Administration

No coalition can deliver sustainable services if political instability penetrates the municipal bureaucracy. Councillors and mayors set policy and exercise oversight; professional officials must be allowed to execute lawful decisions without interference.

This requires merit-based appointments and stable senior management, legal protection for officials who resist unlawful instructions, transparent procurement, credible consequence management, and an uncompromised separation between politics and administration.

As emphasized by guidance from bodies like the Dullah Omar Institute, political change must never mean administrative collapse. The municipal manager and key technical heads, including finance, infrastructure, and supply-chain management, must never be treated as partisan spoils of coalition bargaining.


Institutionalize Coalition Management

Robust coalitions cannot rely solely on the shifting personal relationships of party leaders. Formal institutions must endure.

Every coalition should establish a formal management committee comprising representatives from all governing parties. This body should monitor compliance with the coalition agreement, coordinate votes on budgets and development plans, mediate internal disputes before they reach the council floor, and publish regular progress reports.

Crucially, this committee must not replace open council oversight or operate as a secret executive. Its mandate must be transparent, recorded, and strictly tested against the law and public interest.

Make Disagreement Governable

Disagreement is a natural feature of democratic pluralism; it is not, in itself, evidence of coalition failure. Failure occurs when a coalition lacks a legitimate framework for managing that disagreement.

Agreements should establish a graduated dispute-resolution process beginning with direct political negotiations between party representatives, progressing to review by the coalition management committee if initial talks stall, moving to intervention by an independent mediator when necessary, and culminating in open, transparent debate in council if resolutions cannot be reached.

While withdrawal and motions of no confidence remain essential accountability tools, they should not degenerate into routine instruments of blackmail. Leadership changes must be strictly tied to genuine performance failure, ethical misconduct, or loss of governing support—not short-term tender leverage.


Lessons from the World

South Africa should not treat coalitions as an unavoidable pathology. In countries like Germany, Denmark, Sweden, Belgium, and the Netherlands, coalitions are standard practice because institutions and voters recognize that no single party holds a monopoly on governance.

Urban centers like Berlin demonstrate the power of formal coalitions built around structured policy priorities and dispute mechanisms before executive seats are divided. Similarly, comparative models in Scandinavia highlight the value of executive continuity and clear separations between legislative and executive functions to prevent paralyzing serial no-confidence motions.

South Africa’s own municipal history offers valuable counterpoints. Past experiences in metros like Tshwane demonstrate that coalition politics can successfully drive more open tender processes, enhanced debt recovery, and rigorous council oversight, even amid turbulence. The lesson is clear: coalitions can forge powerful incentives for administrative transparency when structured correctly.

Build a Developmental Compact

A credible coalition agreement must interlock six core pillars of governance: services, finance, capability, integrity, accountability, and stability.

The service component must set concrete targets for water, electricity, roads, waste, sanitation, and public safety. The financial component must commit the alliance to lawful budgets, improved revenue collection, strict debt management, and transparent procurement. The capability component must protect professional administration, fill critical technical vacancies, and invest in municipal skills. The integrity component must mandate interest disclosures, zero tolerance for corruption, and strict penalties for political interference. The accountability component must require quarterly public reporting, active oversight committees, and accessible grievance channels. Finally, the stability component must regulate decision-making, clear dispute paths, and orderly terms of coalition withdrawal.

These commitments bridge the gap between abstract politics and tangible implementation, giving residents clear benchmarks to judge performance long before the next ballot.


The Limits of Legislation

While a comprehensive national legislative framework for municipal coalitions remains a work in progress—with proposals like the Municipal Structures Amendment Bill awaiting finalization—guidelines from the Department of Cooperative Governance, National Treasury, and SALGA provide vital guardrails. They rightly emphasize that no coalition agreement can override the Constitution, the Municipal Structures Act, or the Municipal Finance Management Act.

Legislation can set minimum boundaries, but it cannot manufacture political maturity. The most resilient framework always combines enforceable rules with local flexibility, demanding transparency without imposing a rigid, one-size-fits-all model.


Put Residents at the Centre

Coalition architects often speak of stability as an end in itself. It is not. Stability matters purely because it creates the conditions required to enable investment, professional administration, and reliable service delivery.

The ultimate constituency remains the resident waiting for safe water, a functioning street light, a cleared road, or a resolved billing dispute. Public visibility into executive responsibilities, budget commitments, and performance metrics is non-negotiable.

Share power, but never share responsibility so widely that accountability dissolves.

From Necessity to Maturity

South Africa’s coalition era can either deepen local democracy or entrench municipal dysfunction. Fragmented election results force parties to compromise and listen beyond their core bases, but without rules, capacity, and accountability, fragmentation rapidly degrades into paralysis.

The required transformation is fundamentally ethical and constitutional. Parties must accept that governing a hung council means sharing power without abandoning principle, and pursuing stability without shielding incompetence.

The durable coalition converts political uncertainty into institutional certainty: a published program, professional administration, transparent finances, and measurable improvements in everyday lives.

Voters have delivered the coalition era. Political parties must now decide whether to govern it—or merely exploit it.

You may also like

PiE Digital Afrika
PiE Digital Afrika
GoogleGoogleGoogleGoogleGoogle
4 Google reviews